Andrew Asked: 21 May 2020In: GamesCan’t use a second pistol and I have the second holster.0 I bought the off-hand holster and I cannot use a second pistol. I have tried at the gunsmith, my gun locker at camp, and my horse, and it will not let me use a second gun, please help.01 AnswerVotedOldestRecent MrAnswer Added an answer on 21 May 2020 at 14:14 you equip it at the gun dealer, one off hand and one the other one, there should be an insignia next to each gun, just like the insignia next to your lancaster or rifle. In my case, it’s next to Mauser and if you press left it is next to other Mauser. Having all weapons out of your weapon locker, standing at your horse, you can draw one weapon out in your left hand, and select one for your other hand after that out of your horse.0ReplyLeave an answerLeave an answerCancel reply Click on image to update the captcha. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.